Saturday, August 27, 2011

Divinisation of Human Beings and Humanisation of Divine Beings

Divinisation of Human Beings and Humanisation of Divine Beings

Today we live in a world of conflicts and suicide bombs. A lot of suicide bombers have three basic ideas – one is a fixed concept of God’s revelation, the concept of sacrifice for their own ideologies and individual terrorists who do not bother about the communities at large.
Secondly the conflicts among human beings are either in the name of just war or eliminating terror. The powerful people tend to eliminate the powerless people their lives and their physical bodies are plundered and are destroyed.
In such a context I wish to talk about ascension of Jesus which was the radical experience of the early Christians.
The Gospel writer - Luke prepares the scenario here in verse 3 of 24th chapter by saying, when they (disciples) went in (Tomb), they did not find the body. In some versions, Luke’s notes come into the text Lord Jesus (Kurios Iesous) which is a rare combination of words. Then in 24:52, Luke mentions that they worshipped him. He blessed them. These verses show me three words beginning with ‘C’. Continuity, commonality and communality.
I see here Lukan version of ascension portrays a radical presentation of Jesus. Lukan Christian community wanted to bring out something which was impossible for the people to imagine at that time. But it was essential to retell the story of ascension in that context.
For them ascension means ‘Divinization of Human being and Humanisation of Godhood’. It is a reversal process of 'sarx'  becoming logos which mean the flesh becoming the word.
It is impossible in that context to imagine a human being – Jesus was becoming God or at least Jesus was returning to God, particularly in Jewish context. Of course there are texts in the old testament that says the righteous shall return to God but it is the righteous soul that returns to God (Ecc 12:7...). But here we have another interesting aspect which is: while returning to God Jesus had a human body. It is neither a ghost nor a spirit nor merely a soul. Jesus returns to the Father with his full body. As Jesus was taken into heaven, he was not on his own or in secret, rather all the disciples witnessed his departing and worshipped him. Jesus’ leaving or his union with the father was a communal or a disciples’ community event.
So’ ascension day’ reminds us that God continuing activity and involvement in this world remains while a particular person or event or history comes to an end. In the case of Jesus it is not an end, rather his physical presence in this world is coming to an end as he returns to the father and then sends the Holy Spirit. For Karl Barth, “the ascension informs a dynamic of presence and absence – Jesus Christ’s coincident presence and absence during ‘this time between’” (p. 19). The church is the community that exists in this “time between,” in the dialectical space between Christ’s presence and absence. So the absence of Jesus provides time for the disciples to recognise the fact that God will continue to act in and through the body of Christ that is the church by anointing with the Holy Spirit. In God’s work the continuity that matters even though radical discontinuities are there. We cannot hold onto one concept or one historical even or even one person as such, the church has to move even with paradigm shifts. Even the understanding of mission and understanding of church may change but God continues to work among us in various ways and through various means. Jesus success in ministry was to encourage and enable the disciples to form a self -contained community who in his absence will be able to make decisions of their own with the help of Holy Spirit. There by Jesus is also making sure that it is God’s continued presence and activity which is realised among the disciples. It is not that Jesus disappearing from the active scenario completely but through Eucharist he lives in us as King, Priest and Prophet.
T F Torrance highlights this point, It is at the Eucharist where our participation in the crucified, risen and ascended Christ is unceasingly renewed, that we learn to live as those whose life is hid with Christ in God, and who here and now enjoy ‘that blessed society which we the members have with our Head and our only Mediator Christ Jesus’.
The ascension also means that Christ’s Person, with his presence in power and glory, is withdrawn from our sight, so that we are sent back to contemplate him, not primarily by the mystery of his Being in eternity, but as Jesus who was born, lived, and taught, was crucified and rose again. Christ deliberately withdrew himself from our sight so that our minds might be sent back to the Cross. And as we turn to the Gospel testimony of the Cross, the Holy Spirit is poured out upon the Church, and makes that testimony the Word of our salvation.
Among the Indian churches there is a practice of transfer for pastors after every five years to another parish. Some pastors are so creative and influential that they establish a lot of programmes and projects run by the churches. They are so worried at times about their programmes which may be closed down when the new pastors take in charge. Among some independent missionary movements, individuals make their own sons or relatives as the leaders of the movement when they retire and thus the trust in God’s continuing activity is reduced to running an institution as family owned property. This is what the disciples realise that now we are expected to work in the absence of Jesus as a community on its own. God continues to act in this world in spite of persons, events and even particularities though they are very important and are part and parcel of God’s own presence. Ascension affirms this by bringing in the ‘time between’, that is between Jesus’ leaving and the sending of the Holy Spirit from God. There is a continuity of God’s engagement with the human world and there is a discontinuity that Jesus with his human body was ascended into heaven and thus end of his physical presence in this world. Without discontinuity Jesus’ continued mission in heaven as high priest for us would not happen but without continuity of Jesus’ mission in and through us, there will be discontinuity of what Jesus would have done if he is physically present here in this world. The continuity is the movement of particularity of historical Jesus returning to God and thus becoming a universal Christ, who is going to be present in all Eucharist rather than physically present. There is a movement from particularity to Universality and thus particularity loses its particularity in order to be part of universal activity of God though the particular identity will still remain. There is also a continuity of life of Jesus in God though it was discontinued on earth except through other forms.
Secondly Ascension Day also affirms us a strange concept which is radical at the time of post-resurrection. Jesus was taken with his earthly body and the disciples worshipped him. It is unacceptable for monotheistic religions. Humanity is taken into God. Jesus as a human being with his body has a role to play within Godhood. This is where the strangeness and Oneness are combined. In Godhood there is humanity. It is often thought in reverse. God is Jesus’ humanity.
Hippolytus (236) Will he say that there was flesh in heaven? Yet there is the flesh which was presented by the Father’s word as an offering... and before this there was no flesh in heaven. Novatian (258) while by the mutual connection both flesh wears the Word of Good and the son of God assumes the frailty of the flesh. Early Christian writers affirm that Jesus was ascended into heaven with his human body while the church replaces his body on earth as the body of Christ.
Here the church as the body of Christ too has the role within Godhood. Early Christians has recognised both complexity of this issue and also found a way out for many of their theological problems. When Jesus was ascended into heaven, it broke the duality which many tried to bring upon. Separating the physical world from the spiritual world is what often succeeds in many cases. Detachment has become a day’s reality. One cannot divide the world into a secular and religious world. If there is no separation then there is no division of religious pious world and an exploitative and manipulative other world.
It is also that the humanity is affirmed in God with its limitations. When human beings suffer God too suffer. When human beings rejoice, God too rejoices. This world too matters. There is no difference in this oneness in God. Paul uses an interesting term ‘in Christ’ as a Christian community space where all become one in Christ. In other words, in Christ there is no male no female. I had struggles when Hijjrah (Eunuchs) and HIV/AIDS infected people were not allowed to have communion in one of the churches in India, it was very difficult for us to interpret the body of Christ as inclusive of such people as well. Of course the body of Christ has its values of the reign of God and covenant relationship but it invites all to join in and share these values and relationship in Christ.
Robert W Jenson, The risen Christ as a complete living human person has a body and the church is the body. To have a body he suggests is to be available, to be a physical object available to others. Christ is available in this world and in this sense, the church as the object in which the risen Christ is available to be found is the body of Christ. In this sense metaphorically the church as the body of Christ can ascend along with Jesus in its holiness into God. This is a radical message but not monistic idea where everything belongs and are part of the ultimate reality. This is the strange oneness that is related to rootedness and being one with God. It is interesting to note that human body has a space in heaven. In other words heaven has places for human bodies. It refers to a divinisation of the human body itself. This is a radical message of early Christians. This is one of those basic foundations on which Paul developed the concept of ‘in Christ’ there is no male and no female, no Jew and no gentile. Such theological break through was essential not only to accommodate gentile as part of Christian community but also as part of the body of Christ. Today I see the news about human trafficking of children for sexual abuse and pornography. The body are sold and bought but Jesus’ ascension has shown us the fact that every body of the human beings are part of the body of Christ which cannot be simply materialised into a saleable commodity or displayable one. The duality has disappeared. No more flesh and no more Word both become one in Christ. It demands us not to have two worlds but even in physical world we are called to become the body of Christ and thus live like Christ and thus consider our physical existence very real in living for Christ.
Today people give importance to matter rather than people. People’s physical needs are essential to be met. Their basic needs are not given by priority of social and political institutions. Evenone is after making huge profits and thus many are at disadvantageous positions their bodies are at disgrace. This is where the social responsibility and accountability of the social institutions including business agencies are brought under scrutiny. Physical life of every human beings is very important and so their needs and thus at the cost of such human body the institutions should not neglect people nor reject them.
Thirdly the ascension of Jesus is not an isolated event like in the Old Testament. Post resurrection experience of Jesus is a communal experience. It was not happening to be an otherworld experience of an individual called Jesus. Enoch was all alone at least to interpret the Genesis passage in that way when he disappeared while talking with God. Elijah wanted to the departure event to be a non-witnessed event. Here it is identified as an event that Jesus wanted his own community of disciples to witness. This story has to be seen, told and retold to the people and so Jesus himself asked them to be part of this event by witnessing it. Thus he performs and witnesses God’s love and glory in this event to his disciples which means his own union with God does not happen as an isolated event or an individual event. It has to be seen , felt, touched and told to others. Without such experience of his disciples this event would have become a mere heavenly event which Jesus did not want to happen or even God could not allow it as an isolated event. In this case the salvation can no more be an individual event. One has to make others see, feel, touch and hear one’s own personal experience of God. Without which one does not achieve salvation at all. It means it is a communal event. Without the community’s involvement in our Christian life there is no individual salvation out there.
Thomas F. Torrance: The resurrection and ascension of Jesus Christ means the final completion of our salvation in the objective sense, for Christ alone among his brethren possesses glory, honour and prerogative till all his enemies be made his footstool, which we undoubtedly believe they will be at the final judgment.
In a context where individual salvation is very much emphasised it is essential to emphasise that salvation is communal. Individuals have got the responsibility to their families and friends and others to share what they have as God-experience. Though these God experiences may be irrational and absurd in the minds of the suspicious and rational mind sets, I think our salvation depends on how responsibly our experiences are a shared experience and also stories about our experiences are shared in spite of its less authentic kind of narrative format. I mean when it is a story it is not authentic in itself but we have to share it in spite of its limitations. For me ascension day highlights that God raising up and taking Jesus back to him brings the disciples together and make them part of this ascension process and they become witness to what God does in the life, death, resurrection and ascension of the person Jesus.
Now the information about God and information about Jesus becomes the information of the community which will be shared with all around them. No information about God is solely copy righted by Jesus along rather now from individual it goes to community ownership and even what he has taught also arise from such community faith and narratives.
Intellectutual property rights can no more be own by individual as an individual is being developed or shaped by the community and also the community from where the individual arises has a share in the new concepts that comes out of the individual

Individual salvation which highlights people to get God as their own and propriety Gospel. Do not need to bother about families and others or even responsibilities towards sick, differently abled and other marginal people are neglected.
Individualism is on the rise. It is me, my views and my values do matter. All communitarian concepts are powercentred and are seen with suspicion. I am not promoting the control culture or a return of a old patriarchal or powercentred culture and am not arguing against the individual rights rather I am saying that our relationship with other matters, our relationship with God is part and parcel of our relationship with our own family, our own friends and our own people. Why should I support those elderly. God’s saving act is communal. I mean God can save not merely an individual but via community.
Today starting point of our mission is the pain, struggles and need of the communities. Unless we emphasise the communality, continuity and human commonality with God, we may not be able to highlight within the body of Christ which is church as well. To address the issue of the suicide bomber or another powerful person to destroy someone else’s lives, we have to witness to the world the particularities point to continuity of God and so faiths centred around particular events or particular person or particular things have to recognise God’s continued enlarged activities in this world which is universal. Also We have to emphasise the fact that one cannot kill oneself as we do not have right over our body to kill ourselves rather it has to be at the service of others and thus it becomes part of divine activities and possibly be taken into heaven as Jesus was taken. Also we have to witness God’s continued actions in our lives through our actions, our being and our stories. It is inevitable part of our salvation. Without sharing such a great news we may not obtain our oneness with God. Individualism in its extreme forms is being directly challenged by the event of ascension.

We will remeber them

Wednesday, November 11, 2009
We will remember them
We will remember them.
For many remembering the past is difficult as they could not remember their own wounds. For some remembering the past tradition is difficult because it has oppressed them. For some remembering a few individuals and their stories can be difficult as they were involved in assaulting or murdering innocent people around them. Sometimes it is not only difficult to remember the past but also to live the present with these stories and traditions.
But Judeo-Christian tradition teaches people to remember and retell their stories of past. Without remembering the past there is no present, there is no identity, there is no future as well. It is essential that we remember. Then the question comes to us what should we remember? our good side of our traditions only? Or bad sides too?
We are caught between two perspectives here. On the one hand there are a number of schools that offer a critique about the past traditions, social structures and individuals and their versions of stories as they were used in favour of a few and also to subdue many. On the other there are a number of stories, traditions and individuals who worked very hard within their limitations, their understandings and their approaches to bring unity, service, justice and peace among the communities and nations.
This is where I wish to reconstruct a past, reconstruct the stories and traditions which would enable us to live the present without losing the past. Reconstructing means after the critical deconstruction of the narratives of past we need to reconstruct an alternative which will bring people together rather than divide them, bring justice and peace rather than war and oppression. After destroying an old house we reconstruct it in order to live in it. In the same way we are called to reconstruct the past tradition, history and stories that we can live in a new world where many traditions, many histories and many stories can share spaces and find a new life together.
Let me return to the text in Matthew 5:13-20. In the second part of this Sermon on the Mount Jesus looks like a fundamentalist. In verse 18, Jesus says I tell you the truth, until heaven and earth disappear, not the smallest letter, not the least stroke of a pen, will by any means disappear from the Law until everything is accomplished. Jesus seems to affirm what a normal Jew of his time would think about Torah. He seems to be too literalist here. He wants the traditions of the Torah to be followed as it is. But then he goes on to say 20For I tell you that unless your righteousness surpasses that of the Pharisees and the teachers of the law, you will certainly not enter the kingdom of heaven.
Traditions yes but then you have to live the present realities which demands people to live a life that surpasses legalities, power-centres rather a life full of love and justice. The purpose of following the tradition is not merely to uphold the tradition rather it is to enter the Kingdom of God by living a righteous life. After this verse Jesus goes on reinterpreting the Torah and traditions. In Jesus’ reconstruction of the Torah and traditions it is very clear that traditions should serve the people and provide them new meanings of kingdom of God. Even the righteousness is reconstructed in terms of hospitality, forgiveness, being non-judgemental and so on which are not important words for Pharisees and the teachers of the Torah at his time.
Let me give a bit background to the interpretation of this text by the early Christian writers. Marcion (85- 160) wanted to get rid of the verse 17 from Matthew. Ptolemy (180) noted that by nature the law is incomplete and in need of being perfected. Iraeneus looks at it as if Jesus expands the interpretation of the law by adding his versions. Luther say it is Jesus’ interpretation of the Law that makes the law perfect and interprets it in its true sense. There was a struggle among the interpreters whether Jesus fulfilled the Torah and thus made it perfect by adding more or interpreting it with new meanings in the new emerging contexts. Jesus reconstructed Torah by affirming it on the one hand and by relating it to new people and new contexts with love, forgiveness and justice on the other.
So no tradition is perfect in itself. The purpose of every tradition is to enable people to live a peaceful life with justice. Every tradition is being misused or abused in one way or the other to subdue one human being or the other. But at the same time the primary purposes of the traditions is to serve people, is to bring them to a better humanity, is to bring peace and justice together. So they needed a reconstruction at times in new emerging contexts.
Today there is a call to return to the tradition in order to discover one’s own roots. If we look at our own tradition with a mind of reconstructing it, we may discover new meanings that bring diverse people together rather than differentiate them. A number of exemplary people who were part of the tradition have gone beyond their boundaries. They have set examples for us. Let me give you a few examples today.
First example is Pope Saint Leo the Great. On 10th of November Pope Leo’s day is celebrated both by Anglicans and by Catholic Church. It is interesting to note that the Orthodox churches celebrate on a different day. He was a pope from 440 to 461. He brought the churches together in Chalcedon and thus brought neutral terms that would keep the churches together at that time. I think he was a kind of ecumenist of that time to keep the unity of the church. When Rome was under attack he went to the Huns and persuaded them not to attack Rome and even later vandals were also stopped by him not to destroy Rome. It will be interesting to read and research his sermons, letters and other writings regarding heresies and other issues at that time particularly how he could bridge people in faith and bring about ecumenical task into the leadership of the churches and engaged directly with the realities around in Christian way with a human heart made him to be called Leo the Great and the Saint as well.
Retelling this story makes us to be part of such traditions and indeed happy to be part of such traditions. In a way, remembering Leo means retelling the stories of the Gospel as the life story of Leo himself. Let me also use another example from my own context. We remember people of the past and their stories become part of our traditions. We are called to remember them and retell their stories to affirm our engagement in ecumenism and transformations. G U Pope was a Methodist and SPG missionary to my place Sawyerpuram in 1839. He developed a school which later became a college – pope’s college. I studied my Postgraduate studies in Physics in this college. He wrote Tamil Grammar books, dictionaries and translated many Saiva siddhantha poems into English. He was always proud to be a student of Tamil language which he asked people to write on his grave which one may find it in Oxford. He is recognised as Tamil Scholar and as one who told the world about the greatness of Tamil language to the world. So he is part of our historical tradition and so the government placed his statue at the centre of Chennai. G U Pope and Bishop Caldwell were the first set of missionaries who gave identity to marginalised communities by emphasising their glorious past and thus set a initial stage of liberation movements.
Going back to tradition means remembering our past. Remembering our past means to rediscover our identity. While critiquing some of our own tradition, stories and theologies when we look at some of these great stories we may find ecumenical, liberative and transforming stories within our traditions which makes us proud to be part such past and also take us in rediscovering our roots that nourishes relationship with the other and also become transformative and liberative in our own lives.
Recently I went to the Edinburgh Art Gallery as part of my lecture to the University of Birmingham. I began to recognise religious themes among the pictures. One of the pictures was the execution of David Rizzio in the context of Mary, Queens of Scotts. The artist William Allan has produced this art in 1833 giving the version of the victim. As I continued with these pictures I realised many of them were presented from the victims’ perspective. I may not arrive at any conclusion but may argue that even at that time of 18th and 19th century, the artists were the kind of critics of the power centres and their treatment of victims. They have not merely drawn beautiful baroness all the time rather stories were told from the perspective of victims through pictures and arts. I think Scottish gallery has selected pictures to make the people remember the victims and the need to recognise the victimised people within the past stories, past traditions and past from such perspectives as well.
This is where I begin to find a new way of looking at the tradition – reconstructed tradition where we realise that we are part of the great tradition where people cherished justice, reconciliation and human dignity rather than otherwise. If we are able to highlight such tradition or even reinterpret such stories then we hand over the next generation a life – meaningful and tasty life. The question before us is how can rediscover my own tradition/s and make it relevant for the new emerging contexts today particularly in what way it can make a difference in my ministry? It is to discover the fact that within every tradition of ours we find that there was ecumenism, there was justice issues raised, there was reconciliation and we are not introducing it something new or something contextual rather they were part of our great traditions as well – whether it is cultural or religious.
If we can highlight such stories of the past we begin to give identity to the new generation and thus make our tradition and gospel relevant to them. This is providing taste to their lives and that is why Jesus wants to say to us You are the Salt of the Earth. You are the Salt because it seasons, purifies and preserves. In order to give taste to the lives of the people we need to encourage them to remember the past, people of the past and their traditions and stories which are very much justice oriented and making people to reconcile and live with new realities and thus be proud of their own traditions.
Let me complete this with an example from my own ministry. I went to a church in Bangalore city centre to preach and conduct a service as the minister of the church was on leave. It was a special day as the church was honouring all those who are above 70. I was asked to make an announcement saying all those who were above 70 are welcome to come to the altar to receive a gift and a shawl. The committee has already recognised only 12 people and confirmed them and so I had their names as well. 12 persons came forward interestingly one was not in the list and he was a Hindu and another one was absent. The secretary and treasurer were trying to send him back saying it was not meant for him though the Hindu man argued that he was above 70 and should also be included. The Hindu man was a middle class person but wanted this as a blessing for him as he entered to worship in the church today. The committee members were about to send this person back with a bit of force. One of the influential elders came to me and told me that this is part of our church tradition to include non-Christians in this sharing and told me to take his gifts and give to him. Having heard this I called this person to come forward to the annoyance of the secretary and treasurer to receive his gift. We gave the great gift to this person on that day according to the tradition. My little Christian faith in the Church came back to me on that day.
We will remember them. Remembering the traditions, people and stories is essential as the tradition of Law was remembered, retold and reinterpreted. How can I make difference in my ministry? Do i become part of such glorious tradition where ecumenism thrived, reconciliation was cherished, people’s lives were transformed and new relationships were established. Such ministry will be remembered. In this way the tradition of Torah is still valid in terms of remembering the ways God wanted us to live and witness for God’s love, but at the same time it is not the legality nor the differentiation or superiority of ethical Israelite community which is remembered rather those lives that surpasses such traditions and live the tradition of love, inclusivity and mercy that will be remembered for ever. Making difference in our ministry with the spirit of ecumenism, welcoming attitude towards others and transforming people’s lives in their struggles will reaffirm our commitment to tradition that we have received and will make people to remember us as part of such great tradition. May the Lord help us to be the salt of the earth by rediscovering our traditions in new ways and give taste for the lives of the people today.
Posted by Joshva Raja at 8:34 AM 0 comments
Labels: We will remember them